Interchange-plus vs flat rate pricing: which payment processing model is cheapest at your volume?
Interchange-plus beats flat rate once your monthly savings exceed its fixed fee. See the break-even math at three volumes, plus how tiered pricing works.
Interchange-plus beats flat rate pricing once the per-transaction savings on your card volume exceed its fixed monthly fee. In the illustrative model below, that happens at about $2,950 of monthly sales. In the same model, tiered lands between the two at higher volumes, and its result depends on how the processor classifies each transaction.
This guide compares the three card pricing models as of November 2026. It builds on payment processing fees explained and feeds into how to choose a payment processor. For payouts across borders, see SWIFT vs local rails vs stablecoin.
Key takeaways
- Flat rate bundles every cost into one price. Interchange-plus shows interchange, assessments and markup separately. Tiered sorts transactions into rate buckets the processor controls.
- Break-even depends on three inputs: your average ticket, your card mix and the fixed fees. Rebuild the model with your own numbers.
- In this illustrative model, interchange-plus beats flat rate above about $2,950 a month and beats tiered above about $6,000.
- Tiered pricing is the hardest to audit. Ask for the qualification rules in writing.
How does each pricing model work?
Each model decides how the three parts of a card fee (interchange, network assessment and processor markup) are presented and charged. Only the presentation and the markup differ.
| Model | How you are charged | Transparency | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flat rate | One rate per transaction type, for example a percentage plus a fixed amount, covering all fees | Low. You cannot see interchange | Overpaying on low-cost cards and at high volume |
| Tiered | Each transaction is sorted into qualified, mid-qualified or non-qualified, each with its own blended rate | Low to medium. The processor decides the tier | Downgrades to higher tiers you did not expect |
| Interchange-plus | Actual interchange and assessments, plus a disclosed markup | High. Network costs and markup are separate | Variable monthly cost and extra fixed fees |
Shopify describes interchange-plus as the underlying cost of each card transaction plus a disclosed processor markup, with interchange typically about 1% to 3% of the amount (Shopify, October 2026). For flat rate, Stripe's educational page cites 2.9% plus 30 cents as a common example of blended pricing (Stripe).
Flat rate pricing
Flat rate pricing charges one price per transaction that includes interchange, assessments and markup. It is simple to forecast and easy to compare.
You pay the same rate whether the customer used a low-cost debit card or a premium rewards card. That is the trade. Low-cost cards subsidize costly ones, and as volume grows, the premium you pay for simplicity grows with it. Flat rate suits low or uncertain volume, where a predictable price is worth more than the saving.
Tiered pricing
Tiered pricing sorts each transaction into a category and charges that category's blended rate. Shopify lists the typical categories as qualified, mid-qualified and non-qualified, with the processor deciding which applies (Shopify).
How a transaction qualifies is the processor's call. Processors commonly look at the card type, how the card was accepted and how fast the batch settles, but there is no standard rule. That is why tiered pricing needs a written answer to one question: what share of my volume lands in each tier?
A headline "qualified" rate looks low. Your effective rate depends on how much of your volume actually qualifies.
Interchange-plus pricing
Interchange-plus charges the real interchange and network assessment for each transaction, then adds a markup. The markup is set by your contract, as a percentage, a per-transaction fee or both, so the total varies with card type and ticket (Stripe).
It tends to reward volume, because the markup stays the same while the underlying costs change. It is the easiest model to benchmark against network schedules such as Visa's US interchange schedule, since each line is visible. The downsides are a less predictable monthly bill and fixed fees such as a monthly or statement fee.
Which model is cheapest at your volume?
At a $50 average ticket, interchange-plus beats flat rate from about $2,950 a month and beats tiered from about $6,000, while at $2,000 a month its fixed fee makes it the most expensive of the three. All figures below are illustrative assumptions, not any provider's quote.
Assumptions
- Average ticket: $50. Card mix: US consumer cards, blended.
- Flat rate: 2.90% + $0.30 per transaction (a round example, modeled on the common blended structure).
- Interchange-plus: blended interchange 1.80% + $0.10 (inside Shopify's selected-program range of 1.45% to 2.5% + 10 cents), assessment 0.14% (Shopify's figure for Visa and Mastercard), markup 0.30% + $0.10, plus a $25 monthly fee.
- Tiered: qualified 2.40% + $0.10, mid-qualified 3.00% + $0.10, non-qualified 3.80% + $0.10, with 50% / 30% / 20% of transactions in each.
Cost per $50 transaction
- Flat: 2.90% x $50 = $1.45, plus $0.30 = $1.75.
- Interchange-plus: interchange $0.90 + $0.10 = $1.00; assessment 0.14% x $50 = $0.07; markup $0.15 + $0.10 = $0.25; total $1.32.
- Tiered: qualified $1.20 + $0.10 = $1.30; mid $1.50 + $0.10 = $1.60; non $1.90 + $0.10 = $2.00. Weighted: 0.50 x 1.30 + 0.30 x 1.60 + 0.20 x 2.00 = 0.65 + 0.48 + 0.40 = $1.53.
Monthly cost = transactions x cost per transaction, plus the fixed fee for interchange-plus. Transactions = volume / $50.
| Monthly volume | Transactions | Flat rate | Tiered | Interchange-plus | Cheapest |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $2,000 | 40 | $70.00 (3.50%) | $61.20 (3.06%) | $77.80 (3.89%) | Tiered |
| $10,000 | 200 | $350.00 (3.50%) | $306.00 (3.06%) | $289.00 (2.89%) | Interchange-plus |
| $100,000 | 2,000 | $3,500.00 (3.50%) | $3,060.00 (3.06%) | $2,665.00 (2.67%) | Interchange-plus |
Break-even formulas:
- Interchange-plus vs flat: monthly fee / (flat cost per transaction - interchange-plus cost per transaction) = $25 / ($1.75 - $1.32) = 58.1, so 59 transactions, or $2,950 of volume.
- Interchange-plus vs tiered: $25 / ($1.53 - $1.32) = 119.05, so 120 transactions, or $6,000 of volume.
Treat tiered with caution. If the mix shifts to 20% qualified, 30% mid and 50% non-qualified, the weighted cost becomes 0.20 x 1.30 + 0.30 x 1.60 + 0.50 x 2.00 = $1.74 per transaction, almost the same as flat rate. The tiered result moves with a mix you do not control.
What matters beyond the rate?
The rate is one input. Contract terms can erase a low rate.
- Monthly minimums, statement fees and gateway fees.
- Early termination fees and contract length.
- PCI compliance fees.
- Chargeback fees and how disputes are handled.
- Rate change terms, including notice period and your right to leave.
- Settlement timing and reserves.
- Whether card fees change when the networks update schedules. Visa's US schedule effective 24 October 2026 is one example.
How do you ask for a quote you can compare?
Ask every provider for the same written package so you can rebuild the model in a spreadsheet.
- Your pricing model and a line-by-line rate for each card type you accept.
- Every monthly fee: minimum, gateway, statement, PCI and any other recurring charge.
- The early termination fee and contract length.
- The chargeback fee and the dispute process.
- The rate change terms: notice period and whether you can leave without penalty.
- For tiered pricing, the qualification rules and the share of your volume in each tier last month.
- A sample statement showing interchange, assessments and markup separately.
Then compute effective rate = total fees / total card volume for each quote, using the same month of volume.
What about pricing for cross-border payouts?
Payout pricing follows a different logic from card pricing, because there is no interchange. The cost is a platform fee, a per-transaction fee and the FX spread, and the last one is the one most comparisons miss. A Bank for International Settlements paper from October 2026 puts large-bank FX wire markups at 200 to 400 basis points, and fintech transfer providers at 40 to 150 basis points (BIS Working Paper 1385).
BlindPay combines a monthly plan (platform access) with per-transaction fees that vary by rail and network and are disclosed only in the live quote before execute. Plans are listed on the pricing page. The quote locks the exchange rate and fees, so the amount you see is the amount that executes. Adding your own fees on each transaction is a Business and Enterprise feature, not part of Basic. BlindPay states that no pre-funding is required. For the full cost breakdown, read stablecoin payout API pricing and the payout quotes docs.
The method is the same as for cards: ask for a full quote for the same payout, then compare what the recipient receives.
Methodology and sources
Checked in November 2026. Definitions come from Shopify and Stripe educational pages. Interchange ranges and assessments come from Shopify and Visa. All model inputs for flat rate, tiered and interchange-plus markup are assumptions chosen for round arithmetic, labeled illustrative, and are not any provider's quote.
- Shopify, interchange-plus pricing explained (20 October 2026)
- Shopify, credit card processing fees (22 October 2026)
- Stripe, interchange-plus pricing explained (updated 28 January 2026)
- Visa USA interchange reimbursement fees, effective 24 October 2026
- BIS Working Paper 1385 (October 2026)
- BlindPay: pricing page, payout quotes docs, billing docs
FAQ
More payments articles
See all payments articlesInterchange-plus vs flat-rate pricing: the break-even volume, with tiered pricing compared
At what monthly volume does interchange-plus beat flat-rate? Break-even tables at $10k, $50k and $250k, two card mixes, tiered pricing, a quote template.
Payment processing pricing models: interchange-plus vs flat-rate vs tiered
Payment processing pricing compared: how interchange-plus, flat-rate and tiered models work, a worked cost example, and how to find your effective rate.
How do ACH payments work? Credits, debits, Same Day ACH, returns and limits
ACH moves money in batches over the Nacha network. Credits vs debits, Same Day ACH ($1 million limit today), returns, cost, and where ACH stops.