Skip to content

Interchange-plus vs flat-rate pricing: the break-even volume, with tiered pricing compared

At what monthly volume does interchange-plus beat flat-rate? Break-even tables at $10k, $50k and $250k, two card mixes, tiered pricing, a quote template.

Interchange-plus passes through interchange and network fees at cost and adds a fixed markup. It tends to cost less at higher volume and shows every layer. Flat-rate charges one percentage for every card, which is predictable for small or uneven volume. Tiered pricing sorts transactions into buckets and is the least transparent.

This guide compares the three models with a break-even table at $10,000, $50,000 and $250,000 a month, as of November 2026. Interchange is the fee paid to the card-issuing bank on each sale. An acquirer is the bank or licensed company that accepts card payments for a merchant, and a processor is the company that runs the transaction for it.

Key takeaways

  • Neither model is inherently better: interchange-plus optimizes cost, flat-rate optimizes predictability.
  • In the illustrative example below, flat-rate costs about 2.90% on a card-present mix and 3.50% on an online, rewards-heavy mix, while a low-markup interchange-plus quote costs 2.06% to 2.30% and 3.02% to 3.26% respectively.
  • Markup is the deciding variable. At a higher illustrative markup, interchange-plus on the online mix only beats flat-rate above roughly $20,700 a month.
  • Tiered pricing cannot be compared without knowing how the processor sorts transactions, so ask for the sorting rules in writing.

What is interchange-plus pricing?

Interchange-plus pricing charges the actual interchange and network fees on each transaction, plus a processor markup stated as a percentage and a fixed fee, such as 0.25% + $0.10. The cost layers appear as separate lines on the statement. It is also called cost-plus.

Interchange is set by the card network and paid to the issuer. Scheme (network) fees are billed by Visa and Mastercard. The markup is the processor's own charge. For each layer in detail, see merchant acquiring fees explained. Because interchange differs by card, an interchange-plus invoice moves with your card mix: more basic debit and card-present credit lowers it, more premium rewards cards and online sales raise it. Expect monthly or gateway fees on top.

What is flat-rate (blended) pricing?

Flat-rate, or blended, pricing charges one percentage and often a fixed fee on every card transaction, regardless of the card or channel. The processor absorbs the variation in interchange and keeps the difference as margin.

The appeal is simplicity: you can compute your cost before you sell. As of November 2026, Square's US pricing page lists in-person card payments at 2.6% + 15 cents, 2.5% + 15 cents and 2.4% + 15 cents across its three plan columns, online and invoice payments at 3.3% + 30 cents, 2.9% + 30 cents and 2.9% + 30 cents, payments through its API at 2.9% + 30 cents in all three, and manually entered or card-on-file payments at 3.5% + 15 cents (Square, read November 2026). That page gives no date, and the plan names were not legible in the text we read, so verify the plan before comparing. Stripe's and PayPal's US pricing pages could not be read from our machine, so we do not quote them.

The trade-off is that you pay the same price for a cheap debit card as for a premium rewards card. That is generous to you when your mix is expensive and costly when your mix is cheap.

What is tiered pricing and why is it criticized?

Tiered pricing sorts each transaction into a bucket, usually "qualified", "mid-qualified" and "non-qualified", and charges a different rate for each bucket. Critics point out that the processor decides which transactions land in which bucket, so you cannot verify the rates against interchange.

A bucketed rate hides the underlying interchange and the markup. Whether a transaction is qualified usually depends on rules written in your contract: card type, card present or not, how fast you settle, and whether data fields were sent. A sale that misses the rules is pushed down to a costlier bucket, which is what a non-qualified surcharge is. Visa's table shows the underlying gap: its non-qualified consumer credit row is 3.15% + $0.10 against 1.43% + $0.10 for basic card-present credit (Visa USA Interchange Reimbursement Fees, October 24, 2026). Tiered is not illegal or necessarily expensive, but it requires the most scrutiny. See how to read a merchant processing statement for how to spot downgrades.

How do the three compare on cost, transparency and predictability?

Interchange-plus is usually lowest in cost and highest in transparency but varies month to month. Flat-rate is the most predictable and often highest in cost for cheap mixes. Tiered sits in between on cost and is least transparent.

Interchange-plusFlat-rate (blended)Tiered
How you are chargedInterchange + network fees at cost + markupOne rate for every cardThree or more bucket rates
Cost on a cheap mix (basic cards, card present)LowestHighestMedium
Cost on an expensive mix (rewards, online)MediumOften lowest for small volumeMedium to high
TransparencyHigh: each layer on the statementLow: markup is inside the rateLowest: sorting rules are the processor's
PredictabilityMedium: moves with card mixHighLow to medium
Typical fitSteady volume, cost-sensitiveSmall or uneven volume, simplicityRarely a first choice

At what volume does interchange-plus beat flat-rate?

Interchange-plus beats flat-rate once the savings per dollar of volume, multiplied by your monthly volume, exceed any fixed monthly fee. With a low markup the crossover is a few thousand dollars a month. With a high markup and an expensive card mix it can be above $20,000.

The break-even formula is: break-even volume = monthly fee / (flat-rate cost per dollar minus interchange-plus variable cost per dollar). Below is an illustrative comparison, computed with code. Every input is an assumption chosen for the example, not a quote from any provider, and it is not advice.

Assumptions (illustrative):

  • Average ticket: $50, so $10,000 is 200 transactions, $50,000 is 1,000 and $250,000 is 5,000.
  • Interchange uses Visa's rows effective October 24, 2026, applied to the whole mix for simplicity.
  • Mix A, card present and basic: 85% Retail Credit-Performance Threshold I, All Other (1.43% + $0.10) and 15% regulated debit (0.05% + $0.21). Regulation II status is in legal flux, so this row may change.
  • Mix B, online and rewards-heavy: 50% card-not-present Product 1, All Other (1.89% + $0.10), 30% Product 1 Visa Signature (2.50% + $0.10) and 20% Product 1 Visa Infinite, Spend Qualified (2.60% + $0.10).
  • Network (assessment) fees: 0.14% of volume, the low end of the 0.14% to 0.165% industry estimate The Ascent reported in an article updated June 23, 2026. It is not a network rate card.
  • Interchange-plus low-markup quote: markup 0.25% + $0.10, monthly fee $25. High-markup quote: markup 0.50% + $0.15, monthly fee $30. Both are invented.
  • Flat-rate: Mix A uses 2.6% + $0.15 (the first in-person column on Square's page, read November 2026). Mix B uses 2.9% + $0.30 (an online column on the same page). We use these as realistic examples, not as a statement about Square's plans.
  • Tiered: hypothetical rates of 2.15% + $0.10 qualified, 2.85% + $0.10 mid-qualified and 3.45% + $0.10 non-qualified. Mix A is entirely qualified. In Mix B, we assume the processor puts half the sales in mid-qualified and half in non-qualified.
MixMonthly volumeInterchange-plus, low markupInterchange-plus, high markupFlat-rateTiered (hypothetical)
A: card present, basic$10,000$229.60 (2.30%)$269.60 (2.70%)$290.00 (2.90%)$235.00 (2.35%)
A: card present, basic$50,000$1,048.00 (2.10%)$1,228.00 (2.46%)$1,450.00 (2.90%)$1,175.00 (2.35%)
A: card present, basic$250,000$5,140.00 (2.06%)$6,020.00 (2.41%)$7,250.00 (2.90%)$5,875.00 (2.35%)
B: online, rewards-heavy$10,000$325.50 (3.26%)$365.50 (3.65%)$350.00 (3.50%)$335.00 (3.35%)
B: online, rewards-heavy$50,000$1,527.50 (3.06%)$1,707.50 (3.42%)$1,750.00 (3.50%)$1,675.00 (3.35%)
B: online, rewards-heavy$250,000$7,537.50 (3.02%)$8,417.50 (3.37%)$8,750.00 (3.50%)$8,375.00 (3.35%)

Break-even versus flat-rate, from the formula above: on Mix A, a low-markup quote wins from about $2,900 a month and a high-markup quote from about $5,950. On Mix B, the low-markup quote wins from about $5,050 and the high-markup quote only from about $20,700. At $10,000 a month on Mix B, the high-markup interchange-plus quote ($365.50) costs more than flat-rate ($350.00).

Three lessons. Markup moves the result more than volume does. Card mix moves it more than the pricing label does. And the tiered column depends entirely on the invented bucket rates, so treat it as a demonstration, not a ranking: with other sorting rules it could land anywhere.

How do I compare two quotes fairly?

Convert every quote to an effective rate on your own card mix and volume, with all fees included, then compare the totals and the fine print. A headline percentage alone says little, because per-transaction fees, monthly fees and downgrade rules change the real cost.

Use this template. Fill one column per quote:

ItemQuote 1Quote 2
Pricing model (interchange-plus, flat, tiered)
Percentage markup or rate
Per-transaction fee
Monthly, statement, gateway and PCI fees
Network (assessment) fees: separate or included?
Rate for keyed-in, international or non-qualified cards
Chargeback fee
Early termination fee and contract term
Price-change terms (can the markup rise mid-contract?)
Estimated monthly total on your volume and mix
Effective rate (total / card sales)

Step by step:

  1. Pull your last three statements and total volume and transaction count.
  2. Estimate card mix: card present or not, debit or credit, rewards or basic.
  3. For interchange-plus quotes, apply the Visa and Mastercard rows to your mix, then add the markup and fees.
  4. For flat-rate quotes, apply the rate and per-transaction fee to every sale.
  5. For tiered quotes, ask for the rules that decide each bucket, then estimate how your sales would be sorted.
  6. Divide each total by volume and compare effective rates.

What should I ask before signing?

Ask what happens to your costs when your mix, volume or the networks' tables change. Get the answers in writing. The questions below expose the terms that most affect the total.

  • Is network (assessment) cost passed through at cost or marked up?
  • Can the markup, monthly fees or per-transaction fee change during the term, and with what notice?
  • If tiered, which transactions are non-qualified and what is the rate for each bucket?
  • What are the monthly, statement, gateway and PCI fees, and is there a PCI non-compliance fee?
  • What is the early termination fee, and does the contract renew automatically?
  • Do I get a statement that itemizes interchange, assessments and markup separately?
  • Is there a volume threshold for custom pricing?
  • How are chargebacks and refunds charged?

For what to do after you sign, see how to reduce card processing fees. For choosing an acquirer overall, see how to choose a merchant acquirer. The model sits inside the wider picture in what is merchant acquiring.

For a model-by-model walkthrough, read payment processing pricing models and which pricing model is cheapest at your volume.

Methodology and sources

All dollar amounts in the break-even table were computed in code from the assumptions listed above. They are illustrative and not offers from any provider.

Read how to read a merchant processing statement and spot hidden fees to check a real quote or invoice against the rules above.

This article is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice.

FAQ

One API.
Multiple payment rails.

Blind Pay, Inc. (“BlindPay”) is a United States-based financial technology and payments infrastructure company, incorporated in the State of Delaware on May 2, 2024. BlindPay is duly registered as a Money Services Business (“MSB”) with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (“FinCEN”) under registration number 31000277566153. BlindPay is not a state-licensed money transmitter and does not, in its own capacity, engage in regulated money transmission services. All such regulated activities are conducted exclusively through, and under the licenses of, duly authorized financial institution partners. BlindPay's role is limited to providing financial technology, virtual account management, payment processing, and related payments infrastructure services that facilitate payment flows and account functionalities. These services are provided in coordination with its licensed partners and in compliance with applicable federal MSB requirements and relevant state regulatory frameworks.

Blind Pay, LLC (“BlindPay”) is a Delaware limited liability company formed on June 24, 2025. BlindPay is duly registered as a Money Services Business (“MSB”) with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (“FinCEN”) under registration number 31000318334247 and is listed in the Nationwide Multistate Licensing System (“NMLS”) under NMLS ID #2745309.

BLIND PAY SOCIEDADE PRESTADORA DE SERVIÇOS DE ATIVOS VIRTUAIS LTDA. (“BlindPay”) is a Virtual Asset Service Provider (“VASP”) operating in Brazil. The company is presently completing the regulatory adaptation process required of Virtual Asset Service Provider Companies (SPSAV) under Central Bank of Brazil Resolution No. 520/2025, and remains subject to the transitional regime set forth in Article 88 of that Resolution. Registered address: Avenida Princesa Isabel, nº 15, Sala 1405, Edifício Martinho de Freitas, Centro, Vitória/ES, 29010-361.

BlindPay is a stablecoin API that enables individuals and businesses to move money worldwide.